I have to assume that your dad would rather have you in his life as his daughter than to be estranged from his “son”.
I’m …honestly not convinced he would. And even if he would, I don’t really trust his ability to have that conversation charitably. Maybe that’s not fair to him, but…
Is there an interest you both share?
I was honestly pondering that question myself the other day and not a lot. He’s interested in sports (mostly hockey and basketball) while I’m not really at all. When I’ve tried to engage and watch a game with him, if I, like, ask a question or something he just gets frustrated and annoyed that I’m interrupting. And don’t get me started on how he reacts if I say “good play” or something for the wrong team (mind, the only team I know isn’t “wrong” is the broncos and he watches, like, every game from everyone)… Ask that even before my transition, let alone now.
He used to play games, but I don’t think he’s honestly done any gaming in like 20 years. He doesn’t hate, like, party games, but if it’s a party it’s already not a great time for “real talk”.
He has an interest in, like, politics and such. But he’s pretty much totally conservative, still denies climate change kind of thing. So that’s not a great way to have a nice chat with him either.
Unless there’s something I’m missing, it sounds like you’re implying that you both might be in a better place if you had less of a relationship together. I’m sure you have a better relationship with other family members and want to maintain them, and it’s probably not really possible to do that while also not seeing your dad, but I’m not sure I’d want to set foot in that house if I felt like my dad would prefer that I not exist rather than be who I am. Maybe he doesn’t actually feel that way, or maybe he does but hasn’t heard those words out loud and would be shaken by you telling him that that’s how he’s making you feel.
Idk, I think I would try one last conversation with him about how you are feeling and you can make the effort to try to understand how he is feeling. I’m sure he’s generally feeling pretty conflicted because his political identity is maybe the only Identity he really has anymore, and the only group that is really accepting him is also sending marching orders that his children are the scary enemy. I assume he is surrounded by that sort of messaging all day every day, and he only sees you occasionally. I’m not excusing him or blaming you. It just adds up that there is a sort of tug of war going on and you’re losing your dad to it. Faced with this perspective, if he is decent, he will understand that he’s gonna need to choose to either betray his family to remain entrenched in his hateful little boys club or he can at the very least put his political identity on hold to keep his family in his life. I don’t like ultimatums, but I don’t really understand what either of you is getting out of continuing this relationship at all if there aren’t changes. Your gender identity isn’t a choice, but his political identity is, so the onus is on him to make most of the change here. And conservatives by definition do not like change, so if he puts effort in then he should get some credit. He doesn’t necessarily need to donate to LGBTQ+ causes or join marches or anything like that, but he does need to make you personally feel accepted as a child that he loves, and he needs to make you feel welcome for visits for mom’s birthday or a summer cookout or whatever once in a while. I don’t think that’s asking too much of him. This shouldn’t even be a difficult decision, but it will be because he’s so deep in this shit.
And if he can’t or won’t meet you there, I think you’re well within your rights to cut him out. Invite your mom to come to you for her birthday. Host your own summer cookout and invite everybody but him. It’s not your responsibility to pull his head out of his bigoted ass, which is good because it’s really not worth the amount of stress it would take to yank him free from that cult. But maybe when he sees that his hate group is causing him to be excluded from family events, he will not like how isolated he is. And if not, who gives a shit, you’ll be doing fine without his criticisms either way.
Much love and I’m sorry that your dad is a dickhead <3
He’s not quite as bad as all that. He’s an ass, but he’s self aware enough to at least see when he’ll be perceived as the unreasonable one and back off. I honestly don’t have much of a relationship with him at all at this point, beyond saying hi and bye. My family has what most would consider a big get together every week, my nine siblings mostly showing up with their double digits of kids, all hanging out and having dinner. Without that, I lose a rather large portion of my small introverted social circle.
Mostly, I’ll stick with going when I’m comfortable and leaving when I feel disrespected. It’s shitty, but it’s something. And I can continue growing my circle elsewhere too. Joined a game night group, I see my friends from next city over every now and again. I’ll do okay.
I’m …honestly not convinced he would. And even if he would, I don’t really trust his ability to have that conversation charitably. Maybe that’s not fair to him, but…
I was honestly pondering that question myself the other day and not a lot. He’s interested in sports (mostly hockey and basketball) while I’m not really at all. When I’ve tried to engage and watch a game with him, if I, like, ask a question or something he just gets frustrated and annoyed that I’m interrupting. And don’t get me started on how he reacts if I say “good play” or something for the wrong team (mind, the only team I know isn’t “wrong” is the broncos and he watches, like, every game from everyone)… Ask that even before my transition, let alone now.
He used to play games, but I don’t think he’s honestly done any gaming in like 20 years. He doesn’t hate, like, party games, but if it’s a party it’s already not a great time for “real talk”.
He has an interest in, like, politics and such. But he’s pretty much totally conservative, still denies climate change kind of thing. So that’s not a great way to have a nice chat with him either.
Unless there’s something I’m missing, it sounds like you’re implying that you both might be in a better place if you had less of a relationship together. I’m sure you have a better relationship with other family members and want to maintain them, and it’s probably not really possible to do that while also not seeing your dad, but I’m not sure I’d want to set foot in that house if I felt like my dad would prefer that I not exist rather than be who I am. Maybe he doesn’t actually feel that way, or maybe he does but hasn’t heard those words out loud and would be shaken by you telling him that that’s how he’s making you feel.
Idk, I think I would try one last conversation with him about how you are feeling and you can make the effort to try to understand how he is feeling. I’m sure he’s generally feeling pretty conflicted because his political identity is maybe the only Identity he really has anymore, and the only group that is really accepting him is also sending marching orders that his children are the scary enemy. I assume he is surrounded by that sort of messaging all day every day, and he only sees you occasionally. I’m not excusing him or blaming you. It just adds up that there is a sort of tug of war going on and you’re losing your dad to it. Faced with this perspective, if he is decent, he will understand that he’s gonna need to choose to either betray his family to remain entrenched in his hateful little boys club or he can at the very least put his political identity on hold to keep his family in his life. I don’t like ultimatums, but I don’t really understand what either of you is getting out of continuing this relationship at all if there aren’t changes. Your gender identity isn’t a choice, but his political identity is, so the onus is on him to make most of the change here. And conservatives by definition do not like change, so if he puts effort in then he should get some credit. He doesn’t necessarily need to donate to LGBTQ+ causes or join marches or anything like that, but he does need to make you personally feel accepted as a child that he loves, and he needs to make you feel welcome for visits for mom’s birthday or a summer cookout or whatever once in a while. I don’t think that’s asking too much of him. This shouldn’t even be a difficult decision, but it will be because he’s so deep in this shit.
And if he can’t or won’t meet you there, I think you’re well within your rights to cut him out. Invite your mom to come to you for her birthday. Host your own summer cookout and invite everybody but him. It’s not your responsibility to pull his head out of his bigoted ass, which is good because it’s really not worth the amount of stress it would take to yank him free from that cult. But maybe when he sees that his hate group is causing him to be excluded from family events, he will not like how isolated he is. And if not, who gives a shit, you’ll be doing fine without his criticisms either way.
Much love and I’m sorry that your dad is a dickhead <3
He’s not quite as bad as all that. He’s an ass, but he’s self aware enough to at least see when he’ll be perceived as the unreasonable one and back off. I honestly don’t have much of a relationship with him at all at this point, beyond saying hi and bye. My family has what most would consider a big get together every week, my nine siblings mostly showing up with their double digits of kids, all hanging out and having dinner. Without that, I lose a rather large portion of my small introverted social circle.
Mostly, I’ll stick with going when I’m comfortable and leaving when I feel disrespected. It’s shitty, but it’s something. And I can continue growing my circle elsewhere too. Joined a game night group, I see my friends from next city over every now and again. I’ll do okay.